« "to/for Allah" or just a jumble of lines? | Main | Final diphthongs in the Qurʔān »

01/27/2016

Comments

Lameen

There are quite a few examples of lam yakun in the Qur'an - are they all missing the n in the Sanaa manuscript? That would be a lot more telling than a single case.

There's one context where you might expect the n to be retained given such a sound change, and that's before a vowel. It actually is in the first example that comes to mind: lam yakuni llađīna kafarū... (surat al-Bayyinah, v. 1). That would also explain away yuhini: http://corpus.quran.com/qurandictionary.jsp?q=hwn .

PhoeniX

Well, it is not just the missing n in the Sanaa manuscript that is telling, of course. The fact that it is missing in the Quranic text, even the canonical one, at all is surprising. Why would the n ever drop out in these cases?

Reintroducing the n is easy. Removing the n for no reason has no obvious explanation. I've found 16 attestations, versus 57 with final n:

Q8:53 lam yaku muġayyiran
Q16:120 wa-lam yaku mina 'l-mušrikiina
Q19:9 wa-lam taku šayʔan
Q19:20 wa-lam ʔaku baġiyyan
Q19:67 wa-lam yaku šayʔan
Q40:50 ʔa-wa-lam taku taʔtīkum
Q40:85 fa-lam taku yanfaʕuhum
Q75:37 ʔa-lam yaku nuṭfatan

Q31:16 ʔin taku miṯqāl
Q40:28 wa-ʔin yaku kāḏiban
Q40:28 wa-ʔin yaku ṣādiqan
Q4:40 wa-ʔin taku ḥasanatan

Q11:17 fa-lā taku fī miryatin
Q11:109 fa-lā taku fī miryatin
Q16:127 wa-lā taku fī ḍayqin

Q9:74 taku xayran

There doesn't seem to be much rime or reason behind when the n-less forms show up. Which to me suggests that it is an archaism.

This could either be free variation in the speech of the prophet. Or the prophet consistently had n-less forms, and the n-spellings have been creeping into the QCT over time.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)